I recently sat down with Brandon on The Watchfire, one of the more intellectually serious podcasts I’ve had the pleasure of being on. We moved through Ronald Syme’s The Roman Revolution, Edmund Burke on civic virtue, Montesquieu on the spirit of the law, Tocqueville on soft despotism, C.S. Lewis and The Abolition of Man, and Plato’s five stages of government, all of it filtered through the arc from the Gracchi to Augustus. Brandon is a great host and it was a real conversation, though there was one argument I couldn’t tighten inside the podcast format, and one factual slip I need to fix on the record first.
It’s a slip I’ve now made on three podcast appearances in a row, which tells you something about how patterns stick even when you know they’re wrong. I told Brandon that Sulla was dictator for four years, from 82 to 78 BC. He was appointed in late 82 and held it actively through 81, resigned somewhere in 81 or early 80, retired to Campania, and died in 78 as a private citizen, so the dictatorship itself was closer to a year, maybe two if you stretch the definition. The more interesting fact is that he walked away voluntarily, the only figure in the whole collapse of the Republic who gave up absolute power while he still had it, and Julius Caesar used to mock him for it, saying Sulla didn’t know his ABCs. So, note to my future self, stop saying four years. Caesar’s dictatorship was the four-year one, and somehow I never have trouble remembering that.
The rest of the companion video builds the argument out properly, and you can watch the whole thing here.
Three pressures and one more law
People want a single cause for Rome’s fall, and I don’t think there is one. Inflation the state couldn’t stop, borders it couldn’t defend and leadership nobody could trust kept feeding each other for three hundred years before the western empire gave way in 476 AD, and every one of those pressures is present in America right now. The harder question, the one Brandon and I circled without fully resolving, is which pattern America is actually running.
We opened on Syme, who published The Roman Revolution in 1939 and argued that the Republic died from precedent breaking, one powerful man at a time breaking rules that had held for four centuries, each break making the next one easier, and in his telling there are no barricades anywhere and no crowd storming the Senate. The way I put it on the show was that real collapse is remarkably gradual, because each person breaks one more law, and then one more, until there are no laws left to break. If the American system dies, I think that’s how, through emergency executive orders, agencies making rules with the force of law, political prosecutions from both parties, and officials defying constitutional norms with no consequence, every one of them with a reasonable-sounding justification.
The Roman chain starts in 133 BC, when Tiberius Gracchus proposed land reform and was beaten to death by senators with stools and clubs, and his brother Gaius died the same way a decade later. The Senate would kill its own reformers before it would share power. In 107 Gaius Marius opened the legions to the landless poor, which was brilliant militarily and a catastrophe politically, because he went on to hold the consulship seven times when the law required a ten-year gap, and Rome’s mos maiorum, the way of the ancestors, held only as long as the men in power honored it. Sulla marched on Rome in 88 BC, crossing the sacred boundary of the pomerium with armed legions, and broke the six-month limit on the dictatorship. The Second Triumvirate broke the prohibition on proscription lists, Caesar refused to disband his legions before crossing back into Italy, and Augustus combined offices nobody had ever held together. Each break looked defensible at the time, and once you’ve watched that sequence in Rome, it’s hard to look at America and miss it.
The coin in your hand
The second pressure is money, and on the show I brought out actual Roman coins, because holding one makes it real in a way numbers never quite do. Under Augustus the silver denarius was about 95 percent pure, and that held for roughly 150 years. Then Septimius Severus took the throne in 193 AD, doubled legionary pay, and paid the largest donative, the cash gift to the army from a new emperor, since Marcus Aurelius. Every emperor after him had to pay more than the last, and to do it they debased the currency until third-century coins were bronze with something like aluminum foil’s worth of silver that flaked off in people’s hands.
The American version is harder to feel. The dollar has lost about 97 percent of its purchasing power since the Federal Reserve was created in 1913, roughly 80 percent of the M2 money supply has been created since COVID, and Americans are moving savings into gold, silver and Bitcoin the way Romans hoarded gold coins. It’s the same process underneath, and it’s moving faster, since Rome took two hundred years to get its coin from 95 percent silver down to five.
Falling republic, falling empire
Brandon pushed me on the question I’d been avoiding, whether America is a falling republic or a falling empire. Most people pick one frame, with constitutional conservatives talking about precedent breaking and eroding institutions and geopolitical realists talking about debasement, border failure and overreach. What I told him is that I’ve gone back and forth for three or four years, and I’ve come to think America shows symptoms of both, the decay of a republic the way Syme describes it running alongside the imperial decline Gibbon wrote about.
On the political side, executive orders stand in for legislation and a permanent federal security apparatus, our Praetorian Guard equivalent, outlasts every administration. On the economic side you have debasement Rome would recognize, border defense that costs more than the borders produce, and overseas commitments the Treasury can’t sustain. Rome ran those two patterns in sequence, in different eras, while America is running them in parallel, which is why I push back when people say America simply is Rome, and why a collapse here, if it comes, would look like something new. Actually, that’s what every collapse ends up looking like.
1913 and Plato’s cycle
Brandon and I both landed on 1913. The Federal Reserve Act created a central bank that could print without limit and fund the government’s debts indefinitely, the 16th Amendment brought in the federal income tax, and the 17th Amendment moved the choice of senators from state legislatures to direct election. That last one was meant to fix real corruption, though I think fixing the corruption directly would have been better, and its effect was that the states lost their representation. The federal government came out of that one year with unlimited money and permanent funding, and nothing built into the design to check either.
Plato described the cycle some 2,400 years ago, five stages of government running from the rule of philosopher kings through the rule of the wealthy to tyranny. When I map it onto America I’d put us deep in the oligarchy stage, where the incentives reward political enrichment far more than public service, and tyranny is the stage Brandon and I both flinched from naming.
The exits Rome had
Constantine took one exit in the East and bought another thousand years, and Diocletian took one across the whole empire and bought two more centuries, while the West took neither and paid for it in 476 AD. America has exits too. The honest answer I gave Brandon is that the people in power have no incentive to use them, because the people who could reform the currency benefit from its debasement and the people who could reform the incentives are the ones those incentives reward. Rome sat in that same room during the third-century crisis, reorganized under Diocletian to buy time without fixing any of it, and eventually the time ran out.
If you found me through The Watchfire, thanks for following me over. The Fall of the Republic series is running on the channel now, Episode 115 lays out the Money, Borders, Power framework, and the video up top has the coins and the clips from my conversation with Brandon.