John Rondi had me on The John Rondi Show for a conversation that ran almost three hours. We started in 753 BC with Romulus and Remus and the founding of the city, walked through Alexander, the Punic Wars, the Gracchi, Marius, Sulla, Caesar, Augustus, Nero, and the five good emperors, went all the way to Diocletian and the Tetrarchy, and then got into how the whole thing maps onto America in 2026. John was a great host and it was a real conversation. There’s an argument I couldn’t tighten in that format, though, and I made a couple of factual slips along the way that I want to fix on the record before I build it.
If you came here from John’s show, welcome, and this companion video is where I lay the argument out properly, with clips from our conversation along the way.
Two corrections, plus a small one
The first slip was telling John that Marius fought a tribe called the Cimbri run by a warlord named Jugurtha. I crossed two separate wars there. Jugurtha was the king of Numidia in North Africa, and Marius fought him from about 112 to 105 BC. The Cimbri and the Teutones were Germanic tribes, and Marius fought them in a completely separate war from about 113 to 101 BC, so two enemies in roughly the same window, and I ran them together. The point about Marius as a strongman who piled up seven consulships still holds.
The second is one I’ve flagged before. I told John that Sulla held the dictatorship for four years, and that’s overstated. He was appointed dictator in late 82 BC, held it actively through 81, and resigned somewhere in 81 or 80, so it’s closer to a year or two if you stretch the definition. Four years is what Caesar’s dictatorship looked like from 49 to 44 BC, and I crossed those two as well. There’s a smaller one later on, too. I told John inflation had hit 10,000 percent by 284 AD, and the scholarly range is usually 15,000 to 20,000 percent by that point, so I was on the conservative end, which doesn’t change the argument.
Three pressures in one loop
When people ask what brought Rome down, they usually want one answer, and I don’t have one for them. Three things were happening at the same time and feeding each other, with inflation the state couldn’t stop, borders it couldn’t defend, and leadership nobody could trust. That combination is what I mean by the Roman pattern, three pressures running inside one closed feedback loop for three hundred years before the western half of the empire finally gave way in 476 AD. Any one of them on its own is survivable, and Rome proved that for centuries, dealing with monetary shocks and border problems and bad emperors in isolation. It’s when they start feeding each other that a civilization runs out of options.
On the show I described the third pressure as politicians caring only about right now, getting as much money as they can while the Titanic goes down. That image stuck with me because Rome’s leadership knew what was happening. Diocletian and Constantine knew it, and so did the emperors churning through the third-century crisis, but the people who could have fixed it were the same people benefiting from it running.
Coins you could hold
John had me bring physical Roman coins onto the show, courtesy of my friend Dean Kinzer of Kinzer Coins, and the coins make the argument real in a way numbers alone can’t. Under Augustus the denarius was 95 percent pure silver, and that purity held for about 150 years. Then Septimius Severus took the throne in 193 AD, doubled the size of the legions, doubled legionary pay, and gave the largest donative since Marcus Aurelius. Every emperor after him had to buy the army the same way, each payment larger than the last, and the only way to pay was to debase the coin. By Aurelian the average coin was 4 to 6 percent silver, a bronze coin with a silver wash that flaked off in your hand. Romans could rub a thumb across a coin and watch the silver disappear.
Our debasement happens on an electronic ledger, through quantitative easing and digits changing on a computer, so you can’t see it at all, though the mechanism is identical. The US dollar has lost about 97 percent of its purchasing power since the Federal Reserve was created in 1913. Since Covid, roughly 80 percent of the M2 money supply has been printed, and Americans are converting savings into gold, silver, and Bitcoin the same way Romans hoarded gold coins.
Bought armies and a bodyguard class
Borders fail when the state runs out of money to defend them, and the barbarians showing up is downstream of that. When Rome couldn’t pay enough citizens to hold the frontier, it turned to the foederati, barbarian units under barbarian commanders, paid in Roman coin and given land inside Roman territory to defend Rome against other barbarians. A professional army whose loyalty is bought will sell it to whoever pays more next time, and every civil war in the third and fourth centuries was fought with federate units switching sides. The American military is a professional volunteer force, which is fine in peacetime, the easy case. The harder question is who it answers to when the institutional framework gets shaky, whether that’s the Constitution, the administration, the Pentagon leadership, the defense contractors who employ senior officers after they retire, or foreign governments buying influence through lobbying and think-tank funding. If the answer is more than one of those, you’re in federate territory.
Between 235 and 284 AD, somewhere between twenty-five and thirty men claimed the throne, and many were killed by their own guards. The Praetorian Guard, created by Augustus as a bodyguard, had become the most dangerous political force in the empire, and in 193 AD, after murdering Pertinax, it auctioned the imperial title to Didius Julianus for 20,000 denarii per guardsman. In America the federal security apparatus, the FBI, CIA, NSA, and the intelligence community more broadly, outlasts every administration and holds something like Praetorian influence over which policies survive. Add executive orders on top, with each president issuing more than his predecessors and each administration reversing the last, and you get institutional churn wearing a suit. There’s been no auction here yet, and the thing that produced the auction in Rome, an institutional bodyguard class whose power outlasts the elected leadership, is already running.
The 1913 turn
People like to argue about whether America is Rome, and that argument goes nowhere, since it’s a different country with different institutions, so the question I keep coming back to is whether the pattern Rome ran is running here. I think it is, and it started in 1913. That year the Federal Reserve Act created a central bank that could print currency and fund the state’s debts indefinitely, the Sixteenth Amendment brought in the federal income tax, and the Seventeenth Amendment made senators directly elected, removing the states’ built-in check on federal power and turning the Senate into a second popular chamber. Rome had the same setup by the time of Diocletian, and Britain had it under the Bank of England and the Parliament Acts. Plenty has worked since 1913 and plenty still works, but the incentives shifted toward centralization.
Rome ran the pattern from Marius in 107 BC to the western collapse in 476 AD, about six hundred years. America is 113 years in, a long way from 476 and much closer to the third-century crisis, which means there’s still a decision point. Diocletian reorganized the military and centralized the currency and bought two more centuries, and Constantine put the East on a gold standard and bought another thousand years. The West never took those exits and the East did, so the question for America is which Rome we become. Watch the video for the full version with the clips, and if you want the whole precedent chain behind it, the Fall of the Republic series is running on the channel now, with Tiberius Gracchus, Marius, and the Social War already up and Sulla next.