History does not repeat, but it has a way of humming the same tune. Whenever I study Rome, I am reminded that the patterns of power, culture, and identity never really go away. They just shift and reappear in new forms.
That is why, when I look at certain modern political figures, I cannot help but compare them to ancient leaders who reshaped entire civilizations. One of the most striking examples is the comparison between Emperor Constantine and Donald Trump.
They lived in completely different worlds, but both were outsiders who stepped into a fractured society and forced a cultural realignment that people are still debating today.
Agree or disagree with their methods, they left marks that cannot be ignored. And if we understand how identity and power worked in Constantine’s Rome, we can see much more clearly how they operate in our own time.
This is not about taking political sides. It is about understanding the deep forces that shape nations, movements, and the stories people rally behind.
Rome Before Constantine: A World Cracking at the Center
Before Constantine rose to power, Rome was not the unstoppable empire many imagine. It was fractured, unstable, and fighting over its own identity. The third century crisis had left Rome split among competing emperors, rival armies, and shifting loyalties.
The empire desperately needed a unifying force, something that could bring order back to a population that no longer believed in a shared purpose.
Constantine stepped into that world with a message that was both radical and stabilizing. His embrace of Christianity gave Rome a new story, one that provided a moral and cultural framework people could hold onto during chaos.
Whether driven by faith, strategy, or a blend of both, Constantine understood a truth that still applies today. A society survives when it shares an identity strong enough to bind people together during conflict.
Without a shared story, fractures widen. And once those cracks form, the center becomes harder to hold.
America Before Trump: A Fractured Nation Searching For Direction
Whether you support or oppose Donald Trump, it is hard to deny that he entered the political arena during a moment of cultural division and identity crisis. America was not falling the way Rome fell, but it was fragmenting.
Trust in institutions was declining. Traditional identity markers were dissolving. The political class was seen as disconnected from everyday people.
Trump did not create that environment. He stepped into it, harnessed it, and reshaped it.
Like Constantine, he was an outsider who refused to play by the existing rules. He disrupted traditional alliances, challenged long accepted norms, and appealed to a group of people who felt unheard or sidelined by the political and media establishment. He did what transformative leaders do.
He forced the nation to confront deeper questions about identity, culture, and power.
Two Outsiders, Two Moments of Upheaval
Constantine and Trump share a key trait. They came from outside the core ruling class. Constantine was not born into the old Roman aristocracy. Trump was not a career politician. Outsiders often see systems with fresh eyes. They mobilize segments of society that feel alienated from traditional leadership. They disrupt the expected order.
Both leaders understood something about loyalty. People rally behind stories that reflect their fears, hopes, and frustrations. Both men offered narratives that resonated with those who felt disconnected from the governing elite.
In Rome, that meant a Christian future and a new cultural identity. In America, it meant economic populism, national sovereignty, and a rejection of global technocracy.
You can argue about whether these narratives were good or bad, but you cannot deny their impact. Identity is the fuel that drives political realignment.
The Power of a Shared Story
The more I study ancient history, the more I see the same pattern repeating across centuries. People are bound together not by laws or slogans, but by stories that give meaning to their place in the world. Rome needed a unifying narrative, and Constantine provided it. Whether intentionally or not, Trump did the same.
The question we should be asking now is simple. What story is America telling itself today?
When Rome adopted Christianity as its new center of gravity, everything changed. The legal system, the cultural hierarchy, the moral framework, and even the identity of the emperor were reshaped. Constantine did not just reorganize politics. He reorganized the meaning.
Trump did not create a new religion, but he did ignite a cultural realignment that continues to evolve. His presidency forced Americans to choose sides on issues of sovereignty, tradition, globalization, and national identity.
He shifted the Overton window, redefined political language, and changed which ideas were acceptable to debate publicly. Whether you view these changes as positive or destructive depends on your worldview. But history is impartial. History only cares about impact.
The Legacy Question: What Comes After Disruption
Constantine’s reign reshaped the West for more than a thousand years. His influence was not temporary. It was civilizational. Trump’s story is still being written.
Regardless of what happens next, his effect on American identity and political culture will be studied for decades. He changed the communities people joined, the conversations people had, and the issues people cared about.
One of the clearest lessons from Rome is that disruption alone is not enough. A leader can shift culture, but society must decide whether it can maintain unity afterward.
Constantine gave Rome a new center. The question facing America is whether its competing groups can find a shared center of gravity before divisions widen further.
Unity requires a story everyone can buy into, not just one side.
History’s Brutal Honesty
One of my favorite reminders when studying leaders like Constantine is that history does not care about your feelings. It only cares about results and consequences. You can love or hate a historical figure, but what matters is the footprint they leave.
Constantine unified an empire and set the foundation for the medieval world. Trump sparked a political identity movement that fractured old alliances and created new ones.
Both figures reveal a truth we ignore at our own risk. Civilizations rise and endure when they can articulate a shared identity strong enough to survive conflict.
We may not agree on what that identity should be, but we ignore the question at our peril.
What It Means For Us Today
If there is one lesson I take from studying Constantine and comparing him to Trump, it is this. Identity shapes destiny. Nations that fail to define who they are will be defined by chaos. Leaders can push society in new directions, but it is up to the people to decide what story will carry them forward.
We are living through a moment of cultural realignment just as Rome once did. The choices we make now, the stories we embrace, and the values we defend will determine the next chapter of American history. You do not have to agree with Constantine. You do not have to agree with Trump. But you do need to understand the forces they represent.
Because those forces are shaping us whether we acknowledge them or not.
What do you think?
Comment below and share your thoughts. If you enjoy historically grounded analysis like this, follow me at @jeremyryanslate and share this piece. And if you have a message you want to get onto top podcasts, DM me or connect with my team at CYB Media.